Legion still out in the cold as Remembrance Day nears

Post by Daniel Fontaine in


Remembrance Day
The various Legion's in Vancouver should be given special status in recognition of their service to our country. Photo: Windsor Star

Earlier this year the Billy Bishop Legion in Vancouver was pleading with council to give it a break on its property taxes as a means of ensuring their doors could remain open to Canada's veterans. We contacted the Legion today to confirm they have yet to receive any tax relief.

At the time, Mayor Gregor Robertson simply shrugged his shoulders and pointed the finger at the Province claiming his hands were tied regarding possible tax breaks. Robertson argues the Vancouver Charter currently doesn't permit him to provide tax relief to organizations like the Legion, even if they are in desperate financial straights. Meanwhile, other cities in BC do provide tax relief as they are covered under a separate piece of legislation known as the Local Government Act.

As I stated in my earlier post, I think it's either disingenuous, or ill-informed of Robertson and company to say they can't do anything for Vancouver's Legions. That's because I can't imagine a scenario whereby the Province of BC would take Vancouver to court challenging their authority to provide tax relief to their veterans. Clearly that would be political suicide on the part of the Province if they ever attempted anything like this.

In advance of Rememberance Day, Vision should announce they will establish a program to provide the Legion with some sort of tax relief. They should then work with the Province to change the Vancouver Charter to reflect this new reality. A solution to this problem is not all that complicated. Especially when you consider Vision could easily find $850,000 for costly renos to their offices and foyer on the third floor of City Hall earlier this year.

It would appear I'm not the only one who takes this position. In response to my earlier post, a number of commenters agreed with my position. Here is what Doug Mcarthur (we're not sure if it is the Doug McArthur) had to say on the subject:

The Billy Bishop is a great neighourhood gathering place. I am sure it has to struggle in the face of high costs, including taxes. Regardless of what you feel about wars, service men and women deserve our recognition. I agree, a request to the province should be made by Council. But in the meantime why not go ahead and 0 rate the Billy Bishop and see who tries to stop it.

Another commenter wrote:

A salient feature which seems to be missing in this argument is the thousands of dollars the Royal Canadian Legion raises annually for charity. For instance The Billy Bishop branch alone raises one third of all funds collected by Greater Vancouver’s annual Poppy Campaign. Throughout the year the proceeds from all fund rising events in every legion branch must go to charity. A cardinal element of the RCL’s constitution is that any ‘profit’ made must go to charity. In most jurisdictions this is recognized and appropriate tax breaks are granted. In Vancouver legion branches are taxed as though they are ‘for profit’ businesses – like pubs and restaurants – Shame on you Vancouver. Who’s going to service these charities if the Royal Canadian Legion goes down? Have you thought of that Mr. Mayor? Do you really care Mr. Mayor? You’re well heeled, got a good job and I hope will never need to rely on charity. So I don’t suppose it matters to you whether the RCL and in particular the Billy Bishop branch exists or not. One thing is certain, if you help us to get our taxes reduced you and your party will be welcome at the Billy Bishop when the next election rolls around. If you don’t help us I suggest you give The Billy a miss the next time you’re looking for votes.

I have it under good authority that Billy Bishop is not the only Legion in Vancouver struggling under the burden of heavy property taxes. Therefore, the time has come for Mayor Robertson to stop pointing fingers and start taking action. Prior to the election campaign his Vision team did everything they could to secure the veterans vote and they receieved it. Now that they're in office, it would appear they're turning their backs on a group of Canadians that deserve more than just our respect. What do you think? Check out our new online poll on this subject.


Sorry for the off-topic comment:

I think a comment RSS feed would be useful. Or maybe a function like on blogger for notifications of follow-up comments.


KK, looks like Gregor isn't the only one in Visoin doing some finger pointing. Who cares what the npa did or didn't do. Is this still relevant in late 2009? Either you support the veterans or you don't. Which one is it?

Come Remembrance Day, every politician in Vancouver, who shows up at the Billy, (to be seen) should be approached about this subject. If they don't support a tax break for the Legions, buy them a drink and tell them that it's the last drink they'll ever have in the Legion.

what past councils did is very relevant today,example the one-third model at the village, axed by your local friendly non partisan assoc. i'm just saying why knock vision for something the npa also didn't do, unless the legion had a tax break under the npa, and vision scraped it

There seem to be a lot of "kids" defending Vision in the blogosphere. Maybe citycaucus needs a "no minors" commenting policy so the little scamps can go back to Nexopia and leave the real discussion to us grown ups?

CityCaucus is exactly correct in its suggestion to the City to grant the Legion branches a tax free status. The Legions do excellent work with and for our aging veterans and their spouses. We grant tax free status to all kinds of religious organizations and educational facilities. None do better work and a service to our community than the Legion branches. Yes Mr Robertson, please act on this. It is long overdue.

Check out BCWineLover.com!

Paid Advertisement

Paid Advertisement